【學苑專訊】一二年度醫學會代表盧劻業昨日下午2時19分電郵全體評議員，按醫學會憲章澄清其仍為醫學會幹事及醫學會代表，又表示對評議會主席譚振聲於評議會第九次緊急會議前裁定其席位因選舉問題而懸空表示憤怒及失望。
譚於第九次緊急會議前，裁定二零一三年度香港大學學生會醫學會選舉無效，事源該次選舉的選舉監察官（Returning Officer）未經譚委任，違反評議會附例Section Eleven) II)，醫學會幹事會暫時懸空，其評議會席亦告懸空。
及後，醫學會評議會發出聲明，指出評議會附例與醫學會憲章中有關選舉部分有歧意。前者要求選舉監察官由評議會主席委任；後者則要求選舉監察官醫學會選舉委員會指派，故該次選舉符合醫學會憲章，但未符合評議會附例要求，有待商榷。此外，根據醫學會憲章Section IV) Article 2) ，醫學會幹事會任期應持續到下屆幹事會當選為止，故盧劻業現時仍為評議會醫學會代表。
盧於電郵中，再次闡述醫學會評議會的觀點，並對譚振聲處理事件時屢次越權表示不滿，質疑其是否有適合及有能力出任評議會主席一職。另外，盧於電郵中以中文寫了一段備註，「譚先生，若你天良未泯，請於本周內召開評議會會議，只怕你自欺欺人，日復一日，泥足深陷；陳會長，假若譚先生未能克盡己任召開會議，根據憲章，你應擔此大任。既然重責在你，不才斗膽提醒一句:請好好準備會議細節，望勿再逞一時之快，藉mass email 隔空謾罵，揮灑大好光陰」。
以下為盧劻業電郵全文：
Dear all,
I am writing to provide a clarification of my status as a current member of the Executive Committee, Medical Society, as well as my eligibility to be remain as the MSR of the union council.
On 1/1/2013. just prior to the ECM 9, Mr Tam Chun Sing declared that the position of MSR in the union council should be temporarily vacant, based on his own judgement that the annual election 2013 of Medical Society was void, due to the absence of returning officers ,whom should be appointed by Council Chairperson himself. According to Tam, with the unsuccessfully held election, the seats of executive committee, MS, would be vacant, thereafter the case of MSR.
However, according to the Constitution of Medical Society, HKUSU, Section IV ,Article 2 : ” The Term of Office shall be from 1st Jan (or any date after 1st Jan., when the Executive Committee is elected) to 31 st Dec.of the next year (or any date after 31 st Dec., when the new Executive Committee is elected) ” . Such terms provide us with an insight that the Executive Committee, MS , session 2012, shall remain in term of office for the time being. And me, as the current External Vice-chairperson, shall continue to represent Medical Society as MSR and to fulfill the appointment made in the last Annual General Meeting of MS held in 2012, until the new appointment is to be made in the next AGM. Such issue was raised in the Medical Student Council and statement was released to clarify the fact. (please see the attached statement)
Moreover, concerning the validity of the annual election 2013, MS, together with my status as MSR, Tam has once again acted beyond his authority, by making ruling and judgement without any previous discussion or resolution in the meeting. This strongly violated his duty as a council chairperson and had once again insulted the union council as a whole. Having witnessed his repeated unscrupulous acts that were detrimental to the reputation of union council, I strongly doubt his suitability and capability of being the council chairperson.
With the aforementioned, I hereby express my soaring anger and disappointment in Tam’s ruling. I hope that union council can have a meeting soon in the near future to deal with various matters ,especially concerning the annual election and the motion of no-confidence moved against Tam (which in both cases, unfortunately, Tam has once again failed us, by continuously either ignoring or rejecting councilors’ requests for council meetings with unjustified reasons ), on which I shall be the legitimate MSR to speak for MS , and for the sake of HKUSU again.
PS.
譚先生，若你天良未泯，請於本周內召開評議會會議，只怕你自欺欺人，日復一日，泥足深陷 ;
陳會長，假若譚先生未能克盡己任召開會議，根據憲章，你應擔此大任。既然重責在你，不才斗膽提醒一句:請好好準備會議細節，望勿再逞一時之快，藉mass email 隔空謾罵，揮灑大好光陰
Lo Hong Yip
MSR 12′
28/1/2013
附:有關於醫學會週年大選的聲明
各位會員：
根據香港大學學生會評議會（下稱評議會）附例第十一章第二節，法定監察員需要是評議會評議員及由評議會主席指派。但根據香港大學學生會醫學會（下稱醫學會）憲章第十章第六節，法定監察員是由醫學會選舉委員會指派。此憲章與附例有重疊。基於此衝突，本會認為2012年醫學會週年大選雖然符合醫學會憲章，但未符合評議會附例，故選舉結果有待評議會商議。
而且，本會認為港大評議會主席譚振聲先生於第九次緊急評議會會議前的決定不合乎程序，故應視作無效。根據評議會附例第二章第三節及第一章第四節，任何涉嫌違反評議會附例的事件應由評議會決議而非由評議會主席決定，處理手法有待評議會商討。
根據醫學會憲章第四章第二節，醫學會幹事會任期應持續到下屆幹事會當選為止。因此，現時2012年度醫學會幹事會將繼續留任。
本會對今次事件深表遺憾，並敦促評議會盡快處理事件。
香港大學醫學生評議會
二零一三年一月七日
